I promise that any disputes between us will be argued at your house. Time passes and a dispute begins to brew. Now, I want to argue at my house, not at yours. You pay costs to argue at my house that you wouldn’t have incurred had I done as agreed. Should I have to reimburse your costs?
A Federal Court in Northern California said yes – I have to pay your costs because I broke my promise.
During a project for the U.S. Navy in Djibouti for electrical and mechanical power-plant upgrades, a Subcontractor agreed that any disputes between it and the Prime Contractor would be resolved in a California Federal Court. The Prime is a U.S. company with its headquarters in California. The Sub is a Lebanese company with no regular presence in the U.S. In fact, it appears the Sub has never been to the U.S.
Recap: The dispute has nothing to do with anything near your headquarters/office/house, the Project is nowhere near your office, I’ve never been near your office, it’s probably more convenient for you to argue near your office, which is why you included this term in the Subcontract, and (most importantly) I agreed to only argue near your office.
Result: The argument will be near your office, not mine and not near the Project where we both worked and lived for many months. And, I now have pay your costs incurred because I tried to argue with you near the Project.
Show Me the Money!
You told the guy to do the work, the work is done, and now it’s time for payment, right? But, you only told […]
Reasonable ≠ Ratio
“Circuit court litigation comes at a price, sometimes a heavy price.”
Words Matter
Remember the adage, “what you say today could bite you tomorrow.”
Recently, a Contractor won its argument before the Armed Services Board of […]
Run Through the Base, Not To the Base
Run Through the Base, Not To the Base
Thankfully, baseball season is back. While listening to a broadcast of my favorite team yesterday, […]
Having Your Cake and Eating It Too: Attorneys Fees Without a Contract Clause
How often have you wanted to take a dispute “to the mattresses” (think, The Godfather), but the cost was prohibitive? You have […]
Choose Your Own Venue: Where to File a Miller Act Lawsuit
Do you remember the Choose Your Own Adventure books? If you are a subcontractor on a federal project, where should you […]
Speak Now or Pay Later
This applies to general contractors, subcontractors, and suppliers. Each can be the party preparing and transmitting a form of purchase order or […]
General Contractors Waive Goodbye
General Contractors: When was the last time a private owner asked you to waive your lien rights before you did any work? […]
Unripe Mediation Can Be Bitter
Ripen the dispute for mediation with a gradual exchange of information over time.
