Despite “abhorrent” behavior by the Army Corps of Engineers, a majority of the Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals held there was no breach of the duty of good faith and fair dealing.  Yet, the Contractor recovered almost all of its claimed damages because the Corps forced the Contractor to sign a modification under duress and ignored a significant constructive change.

In this story, two bids were submitted for maintenance dredging of the Scarborough River, Scarborough, Maine.  The successful bidder was 40% lower than the Government’s initial estimate.  Before contract award the Corps requested a change to the winning bidder’s plan at no additional cost to the Government and the Corps revised its Government estimate to be only 14% higher than the winning bid.

After award, the Corps unilaterally reduced the amounts it had agreed to pay for certain CLINs, which effectively cut off the contractor’s cash flow for the Project.

From these facts, a minority of the Board found the Corps breached its duty of good faith and fair dealing.  However, a majority of the Board held there was no breach, despite the Corps’ “abhorrent” and unreasonable behavior.  (A split of opinion on the Board is rare.)

The full opinion has more detail of how unfairly the Corps treated the Contractor.

Appeals of North American Landscaping, Construction, and Dredge, Co., Inc., Armed Services Board of Contract Appeals Nos. 60235, 60236, 60237, and 60238 (August 9, 2018).

Published On: November 14, 2018

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!

  • Sum Certain Blog Post

Jurisdiction is Power

August 27, 2023|

Not bad power, but the ability of a decision-maker (e.g., court) to decide which side is right (or which is more correct). […]

  • Heavy Construction Law | Mediation Melee | Roads & Bridges

Roads & Bridges | Mediation Melee

June 13, 2023|

MEDIATION MELEE| An arbitration case can be costly

Arbitration can be a bridge over troubled waters. In this crossing, the parties argued over […]

  • Written Notice | Roads & Bridges Article | Jon Straw

Roads & Bridges | Written Notice

April 2, 2023|

WRITTEN NOTICE | Beware that strict compliance of the contract might be required.

When an owner replaced a contractor for significant safety violations, […]

Share This Story, Choose Your Platform!