Imagine an incredulous Contractor asking, “Show me in the Contract where it says I’m supposed to do X?” The Government Contracting Officer smugly answers, “even though the Contract doesn’t say so, you must do it anyway.” Is that even possible, when, how? Yes, it’s possible.
The Government OR the Contractor can hold each other to contract clauses that are neither expressly nor impliedly included in the Contract when:
- Such clauses express a significant or deeply ingrained part of public procurement policy; or
- When the party seeking to enforce such clauses is not doing it for its own benefit.
This is known as the Christian Doctrine, named for the case of G.L. Christian & Assoc. v. U.S., 312 F.2d 418 (U.S. Court of Claims, 1963).
Unfortunately, the Christian Doctrine only works on contract clauses and only in limited circumstances. It doesn’t work on statutes. Even when the Statute itself empowered the Government to enter into Contracts, because the terms of the Statute were not expressly or impliedly part of the Contract, the Contractor had no remedy for the Government’s failure to pay after the Contractor performed. (See, James M. Fogg Farms, Inc., et al. v. U.S., Court of Federal Claims, Case No. 17-188C (September 27, 2017)).
Roads & Bridges
Where Does the Buck Stop?
Jon is a monthly contributor to Roads & Bridges magazine. He has been writing the law section for the magazine since January 2020. The link below will take you directly to the Roads & Bridges […]
Pay-If-Paid Unenforceable in Virginia Starting Jan. 1, 2023
As of Jan. 1, 2023, pay-if-paid clauses are unenforceable, regardless of whether a surety/payment bond claim is involved. This is only for subcontracts created on/after 1/1/23.
Also for subcontracts created on/after 1/1/23, the prime must specifically […]
How Short is Too Short
A limitations period is too short when it’s unreasonably short.
Construction Contracting Without Relief Clauses During COVID-19
What to do if your contract lacks the parts to handle COVID-19? Considerations for creating new contracts during COVID-19.
Your Contract Can Handle COVID-19
Uncertainty and risk are not new or novel to contractors. Contracts reduce uncertainty and share the risk of doing or providing something. COVID-19 may have contributed to, but it has not single-handedly created, uncertainty and risk.
Contractors Can Use RFI to Notify the Government
The Board (and the government) should not elevate form over substance in evaluating the sufficiency of a contractor’s notice.
Taxes Due!
It’s tax season again, so it’s time to pay the piper.
Contractor Wins when Government Reconsiders Accord
Ever had buyer’s remorse or second-guessed a decision? When the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers did that, a Contractor won its claim for time and money.
On a flood control project near Nogales, Arizona, severe flooding […]
Claim Certified with Digital Signature Deemed OK
The law is not a trend-setter. It doesn’t readily change or adapt to tech. So, a commonplace practice in business became a dispute when a claimant digitally certified a claim under the Contract Disputes Act.
Jonathan J. Straw
Blog Author
Contact Jonathan
Partner | KraftsonCaudle.com
Download Jon’s Bio
