Adding Terms to a Government Contract without Saying So

Imagine an incredulous Contractor asking, “Show me in the Contract where it says I’m supposed to do X?” The Government Contracting Officer smugly answers, “even though the Contract doesn’t say so, you must do it anyway.” Is that even possible, when, how? Yes, it’s possible.

The Government OR the Contractor can hold each other to contract clauses that are neither expressly nor impliedly included in the Contract when:

Such clauses express a significant or deeply ingrained part of public procurement policy; or
When the party seeking to enforce such clauses is not doing it for its own benefit.

This is known as the Christian Doctrine, named for the case of G.L. Christian & Assoc. v. U.S., 312 F.2d 418 (U.S. Court of Claims, 1963).

Unfortunately, the Christian Doctrine only works on contract clauses and only in limited circumstances. It doesn’t work on statutes. Even when the Statute itself empowered the Government to enter into Contracts, because the terms of the Statute were not expressly or impliedly part of the Contract, the Contractor had no remedy for the Government’s failure to pay after the Contractor performed. (See, James M. Fogg Farms, Inc., et al. v. U.S., Court of Federal Claims, Case No. 17-188C (September 27, 2017)).

Published On: March 14, 2018

Roads & Bridges | Award Upheld in W. Va. Caisson Dispute

jstraw12026-04-15T15:23:16-04:00April 15, 2026|

AWARD UPHELD IN W.VA. CAISSON DISPUTE
Federal court reinforces high bar for overturning arbitration

In 2018, the West Virginia Department of Highways (DOH) awarded […]

Roads & Bridges |Let the Contract Lead

jstraw12026-03-10T13:42:36-04:00March 10, 2026|

LET THE CONTRACT LEAD
Documents offer guidance needed to manage risk without derailing projects

Construction is an industry of managed risk. Whether the prices […]

Roads & Bridges | When is an Invoice Really an Invoice?

jstraw12026-01-19T08:07:35-05:00January 19, 2026|

WHEN IS AN INVOICE REALLY AN INVOICE?
All court decisions are opinions. Appellate court decisions are typically made by a panel of three […]

Roads & Bridges | Clarifying Punitive Damages

jstraw12026-02-17T10:14:14-05:00January 10, 2026|

CLARIFYING PUNITIVE DAMAGES
In June 2021, the South Dakota Department of Transportation contracted for the demolition and construction of a bridge on State […]