If your Claim includes an item for damages with an amount “TBD,” you could lose the entire Claim.
A Claim is a written demand by a contracting party for payment of a “sum certain” or other relief. F.A.R. 52.233-1(c)
For example, a Contractor agreed to provide facilities maintenance and repair, among other services, at Fr. Meade, Maryland. The Contractor submitted a Claim to the Contracting Officer for several cost items. Among them was an item for “anticipatory lost profits” in an amount “TBD. Although portions of the Claim were for definite amounts, the ASBCA dismissed the entire appeal because at least one part of the Claim was not for a “sum certain.” The part of the Claim for an amount “TBD” tainted the entire Claim.
The Board provided some guidance for Contractors. If a “sum certain” cannot be calculated, then a Contractor should specifically describe:
- How to perform a calculation for a sum certain;
- What information the calculation would be based;
- Where such information exists;
- What the Contractor has done to acquire such information; and
- That, due to no fault of the Contractor, such information is not available.
If you can’t calculate a sum certain or you doubt your explanation, separate the uncertain amount from the rest of your Claim and submit it as a separate claim. At least then, it won’t taint the rest of your Claim.
Roads & Bridges | From Roman Arches to AI
FROM ROMAN ARCHES TO AI
Can Construction Evolve Without Risk?
The construction industry blends old with new. From ancient Roman archways and aqueducts and […]
Roads & Bridges | Caught in the Middle
CAUGHT IN THE MIDDLE
New Mexico bridge case highlights the importance of written agreements for changes and delay compensation
In construction contracting, hope for […]
Roads & Bridges | Wait and It’s Waived
WAIT AND IT’S WAIVED
Roads & Bridges | Supreme Court Ruling on Arbitration Delay
Don’t wait to arbitrate! Progressing too far down the litigation […]
Roads & Bridges | Court Defines When Contractors Can Withdraw Due to Mistakes
BIDDING BLUNDER
Roads & Bridges | Court Defines When Contractors Can Withdraw Due to Mistakes
For over 125 years, the vast majority of jurisdictions […]
FEDERAL CONTRACT TERMINATION OR MODIFICATION
The White House has directed Agency heads to “terminate or modify . . . covered contracts.” With some exceptions, there are […]
Roads & Bridges | Maximizing Damage Recovery
MAXIMIZING DAMAGE RECOVERY
Tracking Costs, Avoiding Duplication in Liquidated and Actual Damage Claims
A County and Contractor contracted for construction of a road and […]
Roads & Bridges | Roadwork, Delays and Disputes
ROADWORK, DELAYS, AND DISPUTES
The Subcontract Case In Pecos County, Texas
“Road construction is ubiquitous in our society. . . .” C&C Road […]
Roads & Bridges | Understanding Sovereign Immunity
UNDERSTANDING SOVEREIGN IMMUNITY| Public Contracts and Lessons from Recent Texas Cases
Generally, governmental entities are immune from lawsuits. One exception is contractual. If […]
Roads & Bridges | Indiana Court Upholds Broad ND4D Clause
INDIANA COURT UPHOLDS BROAD ND4D CLAUSE | Ruling Precludes Subcontractor Claims for Delay and Acceleration Damages
This is the story of an Indiana […]
